Beggar and Apprentice: Difference between pages

Revision as of 13:07, 24 March 2023

Information

Type

"For years have I traveled, studying the ways of The Craft. Which craft, you ask? Simply that of the simple folk. Nothing to worry about. Not yet."

Appears in

Cult of the Clocktower Episode by Andrew Nathenson

You need to enable JavaScript to play this audio

Summary

"On your 1st night, you gain a Townsfolk ability (if good) or a Minion ability (if evil)."

The Apprentice has either a Townsfolk or a Minion ability.

A good Apprentice gains a Townsfolk ability. An evil Apprentice gains a Minion ability. They have this ability until they die.
The Apprentice learns their ability on their first night, and they may act that night if the character whose ability they gain would do so.
Only abilities listed on the character sheet may be gained.
If the Apprentice gains an ability that normally only functions on the first night of the game, such as the Grandmother’s, it functions on the Apprentice’s first night instead.
The Apprentice does not literally become the character whose ability they gain. They are the Apprentice, a Traveller, so they may be exiled but not executed, and they do not count toward the number of alive players to see if evil wins due to just two players being alive. Also, other characters’ abilities that detect characters would detect the Apprentice as the Apprentice.

How to Run

During the first night after the Apprentice enters play, wake the Apprentice. Show them the YOU ARE info token, then a Townsfolk or Minion token. In the Grimoire, replace the Apprentice token with that character token, and mark them with the IS THE APPRENTICE reminder. That player remains the Apprentice but gains the ability of their character token.

You will almost certainly want to choose a not-in-play character ability, because there is only one of each character token and the Apprentice needs to use that token.

Examples

The evil Apprentice gains the Assassin ability. That night, they kill the Fool.

The good Apprentice gains the Chambermaid ability. From now on, they learn who wakes at night. Later, the Gambler guesses that the Apprentice is the Tea Lady. The Gambler dies, because the Apprentice is not the Tea Lady, but the Apprentice.

Tips & Tricks (if you are good)

The strategy that you employ will depend almost entirely on which Townsfolk ability you gain. If you become the Gambler, then play the game as you would a normal Gambler. If you become a Sailor, then play the game as if you were a Sailor.

Feel free to lie about which character ability you gained. If you lie that you gained the Courtier's power, you may successfully lure the Demon into attacking you. The good team losing a Traveller at night is a much more favorable outcome than the good team losing a Townsfolk (because Travellers don't count as players for evil's "two players left alive" victory condition), so by tricking the Demon into attacking you, you've helped the good team. Similarly, you can lie about who you are to prevent the evil team from attacking you. An Assassin is unlikely to use their precious ability to kill an Apprentice Fool... but they may do so to remove an Apprentice Exorcist!

It is possible that you become the same character as someone else in play, but it is unlikely. Since there is only 1 of each token, the Storyteller will more often give you a not-in-play character's ability. Treat any players claiming to be the same character as you with suspicion.

Tips & Tricks (if you are evil)

The strategy that you employ will depend almost entirely on which Minion ability you gain. If you become the Mastermind, then play the game as you would a normal Mastermind. If you become a Devil's Advocate, then play the game as if you were a Devil's Advocate.

Pick a Townsfolk character, and claim to have gained that role's ability. If you were the good Apprentice, you would have been woken and shown a Townsfolk whose ability you gain. Be prepared for the other players to ask you questions about which Townsfolk ability you have, and how you are using it.

If you claim to be the same character as a good player, you can either claim that the Storyteller has given you a duplicate ability as that player (which is not common, but possible), or that that player is lying about who they are. Either way, it's not the end of the world, but you may have to contend with that player one on one if you want to survive.

Your ability will be extremely helpful to the evil team, but only if you can learn who they are and co-ordinate with them. As the Devil's Advocate, you can save evil players from death, but you'll need to know who they are first. As the Assassin, you can kill any good player needed, but you'll need to know which players are good first. As the Mastermind, you can win the game by getting the Demon executed, but you'll need to communicate to the Minions that this is what you are doing so that they know to vote. If you are the Godfather, you'll need to know which players are Outsiders, and not Minions pretending to be Outsiders. Whichever Minion ability you gain, you'll work best if you can talk to the Demon, let them know that you are evil, find out who the Minions are, and communicate with them well.

@@ Line 6: / Line 6: @@
 		<div id='character-details'>
-			[[File:icon_beggar.png|250px]]
+			[[File:icon_apprentice.png|250px]]
 			<span style="display: block; color: black; font-size: 20px; text-align: center; margin-top: 10px;">Information</span>
@@ Line 16: / Line 16: @@
 			</table>
-			<p class='flavour'>"Alms for the poor, good Sir? Spare a coin, Madam? Thank you. God bless! You're a right kind soul and no mistake! I'll have some swanky nosh tonight, I will!"</p>
+			<p class='flavour'>"For years have I traveled, studying the ways of The Craft. Which craft, you ask? Simply that of the simple folk. Nothing to worry about. Not yet."</p>
 			<span style="display: block; color: black; font-size: 20px; text-align: center;">Appears in</span>
-			[[File:logo_trouble_brewing.png|100px]]
+			[[File:logo_bad_moon_rising.png|100px]]
 			<span style="display: block; color: black; font-size: 20px; text-align: center; margin-top: 20px;">Cult of the Clocktower Episode</span>
 			<span style="display: block; color: black; font-size: 14px; text-align: center;">by Andrew Nathenson</span>
-			<div style='padding-bottom: 10px' class="html5audio" data-file="https://anchor.fm/s/daf1f9c/podcast/play/17153879/https%3A%2F%2Fd3ctxlq1ktw2nl.cloudfront.net%2Fstaging%2F2020-6-27%2Fc9ae121e-f627-ee0e-88d8-04cac9a66bc6.mp3">You need to enable JavaScript to play this audio</div>
+			<div style='padding-bottom: 10px' class="html5audio" data-file="https://anchor.fm/s/daf1f9c/podcast/play/66453583/https%3A%2F%2Fd3ctxlq1ktw2nl.cloudfront.net%2Fstaging%2F2023-2-13%2F317700945-44100-2-983f553c36513.m4a">You need to enable JavaScript to play this audio</div>
 		</div>
@@ Line 35: / Line 35: @@
 		<div class="small-12 large-6 columns">
 == Summary ==
-"You must use a vote token to vote. If a dead player gives you theirs, you learn their alignment. You are sober and healthy."
+"On your 1st night, you gain a Townsfolk ability (if good) or a Minion ability (if evil)."
-The Beggar can not vote unless someone gives them a token to use, but they learn if the player that does so is good or evil.
+The Apprentice has either a Townsfolk or a Minion ability.
-* The Beggar cannot raise their hand to vote at all unless they have a vote token.
+* A good Apprentice gains a Townsfolk ability. An evil Apprentice gains a Minion ability. They have this ability until they die.
-* When they do vote, they lose one vote token. If they have more than one, they may only use one at a time.
+* The Apprentice learns their ability on their first night, and they may act that night if the character whose ability they gain would do so.
-* Only a dead player may give their vote token to the Beggar, after which that dead player cannot vote. Each dead player decides for themself whether to give the Beggar their vote token. No one, including the Beggar, may move a player’s vote token on their behalf.
+* Only abilities listed on the character sheet may be gained.
-* When a player gives their vote token to the Beggar, the Beggar learns whether that player is good or evil.
+* If the Apprentice gains an ability that normally only functions on the first night of the game, such as the Grandmother’s, it functions on the Apprentice’s first night instead.
-* The Beggar can still nominate freely, and can still vote for an exile freely, because exiles are not affected by abilities.
+* The Apprentice does not literally become the character whose ability they gain. They are the Apprentice, a Traveller, so they may be exiled but not executed, and they do not count toward the number of alive players to see if evil wins due to just two players being alive. Also, other characters’ abilities that detect characters would detect the Apprentice as the Apprentice.
-* If the Beggar dies, they gain one vote token to use while dead, just like any other character would. However, the Beggar loses all their previously acquired vote tokens.
-* If the Beggar would become drunk or poisoned, they do not.
-* The ability to donate vote tokens is unique to the Beggar ability. Players may not give their vote token to a player that is not the Beggar, whether or not a Beggar is in play.
 		</div>
@@ Line 51: / Line 48: @@
 == How to Run ==
-The Beggar cannot vote unless they have a vote token. They lose one vote token each time they vote.
+During the first night after the Apprentice enters play, wake the Apprentice. Show them the '''YOU ARE''' info token, then a Townsfolk or Minion token. In the Grimoire, replace the Apprentice token with that character token, and mark them with the '''IS THE APPRENTICE''' reminder. That player remains the Apprentice but gains the ability of their character token.
-During the day, a dead player can declare that they give their vote token to the Beggar. Transfer the vote token to the Beggar and privately tell the Beggar the alignment of that player.
+<div class="example" style="color: #5d2123; font-style: italic; font-family: GoudyOldStyle;">
+You will almost certainly want to choose a not-in-play character ability, because there is only one of each character token and the Apprentice needs to use that token.
+</div>
 		</div>
@@ Line 65: / Line 64: @@
 			<div class='example'>
-				The Beggar cannot vote. On the fourth day, the {{Good|Monk}} gives her vote token to the Beggar. The Beggar may now vote (once), and learns that the player is good. The Beggar is evil and tells the group that the {{Good|Monk}} player is evil.
+				The evil Apprentice gains the {{Evil|Assassin}} ability. That night, they kill the {{Good|Fool}}.
 			</div>
 			<div class='example'>
-				The good Beggar has three vote tokens. The {{Good|Recluse}} gives the Beggar their vote token, and the Beggar learns that they are evil. That day, the Beggar dies, and loses all their vote tokens except for one.
+				The good Apprentice gains the {{Good|Chambermaid}} ability. From now on, they learn who wakes at night. Later, the {{Good|Gambler}} guesses that the Apprentice is the {{Good|Tea Lady}}. The {{Good|Gambler}} dies, because the Apprentice is not the {{Good|Tea Lady}}, but the Apprentice.
 			</div>
@@ Line 81: / Line 80: @@
 == Tips & Tricks (if you are good) ==
-* You definitely want to learn the alignment of at least one player, but don't get too greedy. Learning 1 or 2 player's alignment could mean that 1 or 2 good players can no longer vote - this is probably acceptable. But learning 5 players' alignment could mean that 5 good players can no longer vote - and that gives evil the majority vote at the next execution, granting evil the win. Gain a vote token or two... or three... but know when to stop.
+* The strategy that you employ will depend almost entirely on which Townsfolk ability you gain. If you become the {{Good|Gambler}}, then play the game as you would a normal {{Good|Gambler}}. If you become a {{Good|Sailor}}, then play the game as if you were a {{Good|Sailor}}.
-* Tell the truth about good players who give you their vote token. You trust them. They will probably trust you. Have a private conversation about your combined strategy for the future, and tell the group that they are good. You can trust whatever information this good player has due to their character ability, so use that to your advantage and let them help you decide who to vote for.
-* Lie about a good player who gave you their vote token. If you tell the group that a good player is in fact evil, the Demon or its Minions may seek you out and tell you who they are, believing that you are evil too. This could be amazing information. Either way, you'll want to tell the group that you were lying before the game ends, and reveal your strategy to them, otherwise they may believe that you are evil, or that the good player who selflessly gave you their token is evil.
-* If an evil player is foolish enough or brave enough to give you their vote token, tell the truth about their alignment. Tell the group that the player is evil, and be prepared for that player to accuse you of being evil. Since it is rare for evil players to give their vote to a good beggar (but some will do so because it is so unexpected), you may find it difficult to convince the group that they are evil. It will be easier to convince the group if you can get a good player's vote token as well, as that good player will probably help you.
-* If an evil player has given you their vote token, you may want to lie about their alignment. Tell the group they they are good - this may convince the evil players that you are evil, and will encourage more evil players to give you their vote token. On the final day, you can reveal the truth.
-* You can't vote. So, when you do get a vote token, use it very, very wisely. This is especially important because you may have removed a good player's ability to vote when you took their token, which means that good has less voting power overall. Make your vote count by saving it until the final day, or waiting to use it when your vote will decide whether a player is executed or not.
+* Feel free to lie about which character ability you gained. If you lie that you gained the {{Good|Courtier}}'s power, you may successfully lure the Demon into attacking you. The good team losing a Traveller at night is a much more favorable outcome than the good team losing a Townsfolk (because Travellers don't count as players for evil's "two players left alive" victory condition), so by tricking the Demon into attacking you, you've helped the good team. Similarly, you can lie about who you are to prevent the evil team from attacking you. An {{Evil|Assassin}} is unlikely to use their precious ability to kill an Apprentice {{Good|Fool}}... but they may do so to remove an Apprentice {{Good|Exorcist}}!
-* Be proactive in getting players to give you their vote token. Ask. Demand. Bargain. Beg. Others will not usually volunteer to give you their token, because they have other things on their mind, but will often consider it if you pester them a little.
+* It is possible that you become the same character as someone else in play, but it is unlikely. Since there is only 1 of each token, the Storyteller will more often give you a not-in-play character's ability. Treat any players claiming to be the same character as you with suspicion.
 		</div>
@@ Line 103: / Line 94: @@
 == Tips & Tricks (if you are evil) ==
-* Learn the alignment of as many players as possible. Take vote tokens from as many players as possible. Even though by talking to the Demon you can learn the alignments of all players quickly, the more players that give you their vote tokens, the more players will not be able to vote on the final day. You'll be able to vote as much as you want, and that is a powerful enough ability to win the game. Good players often don't realize how powerful their dead vote is - 1 player giving it away to an evil Beggar might not make much difference, but 4 players doing so will make a huge difference.
+* The strategy that you employ will depend almost entirely on which Minion ability you gain. If you become the {{Evil|Mastermind}}, then play the game as you would a normal {{Evil|Mastermind}}. If you become a {{Evil|Devil's Advocate}}, then play the game as if you were a {{Evil|Devil's Advocate}}.
-* When good players give your their token, tell the truth about their alignment in order to gain their trust. If you publicly tell the group that a good player is good, that goes some way in confirming their legitimacy (and therefore their information), but you may be able to convince more players to give you their token. You can lie about their alignment at a later date.
-* Lie about good players' alignment, if you think that you can get away with it. It is much more common for good players to give their vote tokens to Beggars, so claiming that an evil player has done so is a difficult bluff. But, it is possible, and if you succeed, you have not only convinced the group of the illegitimacy of their information, you have gained a vote and convinced them of your goodness. The good player will kick and scream and do everything they can to convince the group that you are evil, so be prepared.
-* Lie about evil players alignment, if evil players give you their tokens. There is usually not much to be gained by telling the group that an evil player is evil, beyond making yourself look good. Sure, you'll get the benefit of looking more trustworthy (and maybe even getting another player to give up their vote token), but you've sacrificed the evil player to do so. The {{Good|Chef}}, {{Good|Empath}}, {{Good|Investigator}} and {{Good|Undertaker}} in particular are very good at using the simple fact that one player is evil to deduce the alignment of several other players.
-* Tell the truth about evil players to build trust. But do so rarely. Very rarely. Since it is so unlikely that an evil Beggar would actually tell the group the truth about an evil player's alignment, when you actually do it, it may be believed. You'll want to make sure the payoff is worth it though. It can be worth it if the evil player was heavily suspicious anyway, or if the evil player was the third or fourth player to give you their vote token. In such circumstances, building the group's faith that you are good can give you the edge and keep you alive.
+* Pick a Townsfolk character, and claim to have gained that role's ability. If you were the good Apprentice, you would have been woken and shown a Townsfolk whose ability you gain. Be prepared for the other players to ask you questions about which Townsfolk ability you have, and how you are using it.
-* Use your vote wisely or throw it away. Either way, it doesn't really matter. What is important is that you '''look''' like you use your vote wisely, and that you save at least one vote token for the final day. The final day is all that really matters, so who you vote for before that point is mostly about making you look trustworthy so that you can survive until the final day.
+* If you claim to be the same character as a good player, you can either claim that the Storyteller has given you a duplicate ability as that player (which is not common, but possible), or that that player is lying about who they are. Either way, it's not the end of the world, but you may have to contend with that player one on one if you want to survive.
-* Be proactive in getting players to give you their vote token. Ask. Demand. Bargain. Beg. Others will not usually volunteer to give you their token, because they have other things on their mind, but will often consider it if you pester them a little.
+* Your ability will be extremely helpful to the evil team, but only if you can learn who they are and co-ordinate with them. As the {{Evil|Devil's Advocate}}, you can save evil players from death, but you'll need to know who they are first. As the {{Evil|Assassin}}, you can kill any good player needed, but you'll need to know which players are good first. As the {{Evil|Mastermind}}, you can win the game by getting the Demon executed, but you'll need to communicate to the Minions that this is what you are doing so that they know to vote. If you are the {{Evil|Godfather}}, you'll need to know which players are Outsiders, and not Minions pretending to be Outsiders. Whichever Minion ability you gain, you'll work best if you can talk to the Demon, let them know that you are evil, find out who the Minions are, and communicate with them well.
 		</div>